They did it. Oh my gosh what did they do. I hate my players as much as the other DM but I think I might have gone too far this time. Rather I let them go to far.
With the mysterious caretaker only offering half answers, the group becomes more confused and hesitantly enter a deal. I test their patience by purposely making things confusing. They become fixated on the idea of a new pet. Finally Edan begs his old Patron for help. I think it was at this point everyone decided they are going to kill the goddess, Silvanus.
With some Startling revelations about their host Philio the wizard the band of fools debate what their next course of action is. Sulyvahn loses an argument to Mark but still, the group continues on their original mission. Finally I get my party members freaked out just from the atmosphere.